bedrooms
5
bathrooms
2
square feet
1,872
Acreage
1.02
Open Houses
-
year built
1899
Full Baths
1
Half Baths
1
A Divine Opportunity Awaits — Historic Church & Parsonage on Over 2 Acres~ Calling all dreamers, doers, and visionaries—here’s your chance to own not one, but two iconic properties brimming with history, character, and endless potential. Nestled in a charming setting, this offering includes a stately c.1870 brick church (approx. 10,900 SF) and a classic c.1899 four-bedroom parsonage, both on separate parcels totaling over 2.4 acres. These properties are being sold together and await your inspired transformation. The church is a showstopper: soaring 25-foot ceilings, original stained glass windows, a working bell tower with spiral stairs, and even the original pipe organ. The main chapel comfortably seats up to 196 guests and would make a jaw-dropping event venue, community space, brewery, or creative arts center. There’s a full lower level with a large kitchen and gathering area, plus second-floor rooms perfect for offices, studios, or green rooms. A detached 3-car garage/storage barn adds even more utility. The adjacent parsonage, a classic 1,872 SF residence with natural woodwork and built-ins, is ripe for restoration. Featuring 4 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, and vintage 1960s interiors, it was recently occupied and remains fully functional. The first floor offers generous living and entertaining spaces, including a den or potential 5th bedroom and an attached 2-car garage. This is more than a listing—it's a passion project waiting for the right person to reimagine its future. Whether your vision is to preserve, repurpose, or revive, the canvas is here. NOTE: Sale includes both properties and is subject to NYS Attorney General approval. PROOF OF FUNDS WITH ALL OFFERS
Location | |
Subdivision | - |
County | Erie |
Elementary School | - |
Middle School | - |
High School | - |
Find out more
Tell us who you are, and we will have someone reach out to you.
MLS number: R1602827
Listing agent:
Andrew M. Kachaylo
#10491203181
Listing broker:
Re/Max Hometown Choice
(585) 738-7059
Copyright © 2025 New York State Alliance of MLSs, LLC. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
[source]
Last update: Tuesday, April 29 2025 at 11:03 p.m. EDT
Kotohomes National
Other listings you might be interested in
$299,999
5 Bed •
2 Bath •
1,888 ft²
5462 N Byron Road
Elba, NY 14058
$270,000
5 Bed •
2 Bath •
3,072 ft²
7486 Tenefly Road
Pike, NY 14536
$399,900
5 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,952 ft²
1359 Transit Road
Kendall, NY 14477
$289,900
4 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,080 ft²
6322 Arnold Road
Elba, NY 14058
$229,900
4 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,218 ft²
1750 Kent Road
Carlton, NY 14477
$279,500
4 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,036 ft²
2864 Retsof Avenue
York, NY 14539
$525,000
5 Bed •
3 Bath •
2,926 ft²
172 Colby Street
Ogden, NY 14559
$749,900
4 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,572 ft²
3989 West Main St Rd
Batavia, NY 14020
$449,900
4 Bed •
3 Bath •
1,999 ft²
7421 Cedar Street
Newstead, NY 14001
$239,900
4 Bed •
1 Bath •
1,764 ft²
125 Ogden Parma Town Line Road
Ogden, NY 14559
$319,000
4 Bed •
1 Bath •
1,683 ft²
11551 Armison Road
Hume, NY 14735
$279,900
7 Bed •
2 Bath •
2,769 ft²
10341 Rushford Road
Centerville, NY 14744